Press Law

The Key Points

Press law is a specific branch of law that governs the exercise of freedom of expression and information in the media. This legal discipline, at the intersection of civil law, criminal law, and fundamental freedoms, aims to reconcile freedom of expression, a cornerstone of any democratic society, with other fundamental rights such as the right to privacy, the right to one's image, and the protection of reputation.

​

Freedom of the press, enshrined by the law of July 29, 1881, forms the foundation of press law in France. This historic law, amended numerous times but still in effect, defines the legal framework for journalistic and editorial activities. It establishes a delicate balance between freedom of expression and the responsibility of the media.

​

The main aspects of press law include:

​

• Defamation and Insult: Defamation involves the allegation or imputation of a fact that harms a person’s honor or reputation. Insult, on the other hand, is an offensive expression, a term of contempt or invective that does not contain the imputation of any specific fact. These offenses can be public or non-public, with different liability regimes.

​

• Right of Reply: The law allows any person named or identified in a press article to have their response published free of charge in the same media, under certain conditions.

​

• Protection of Journalistic Sources: The confidentiality of sources is a fundamental principle, protected by law, allowing journalists not to disclose the origin of their information.

​

• Respect for Privacy and the Right to One's Image: The media must respect these fundamental rights, except in cases related to current events or the public interest of the information.

​

• Presumption of Innocence: The media must ensure that individuals under investigation or judicial instruction are not presented as guilty before any conviction.

​

• Specific Press Offenses: This includes incitement to crimes and offenses, the glorification of certain crimes, the disclosure of information related to civil party status, etc.

​

• Cascading Liability: This principle specific to press law establishes a hierarchy of criminal liability in the case of press offenses (publication director, author, printer, etc.).

​

• Online Liability: This specific area is governed by the Law on Confidence in the Digital Economy (LCEN), which determines the responsibilities of various internet actors based on their role (content hosts, editors, access providers, etc.)

​

The role of a lawyer specializing in press law is crucial and multifaceted:

​

• Legal Advice: The lawyer intervenes before publications to check the legality of content, assess legal risks, and suggest potential modifications.

​

• Defense in case of legal action: The lawyer represents media outlets, journalists, or publishers facing press offenses, developing defense strategies based on truth exception, good faith, or other specific legal defenses.

​

• Legal Action: The lawyer may act on behalf of individuals who believe their rights have been violated by a publication (defamation, invasion of privacy, etc.).

​

• Negotiation: The lawyer can intervene to negotiate right of reply, corrections, or amicable settlements in case of disputes.

​

• Training: Specialized lawyers provide training for media professionals on the legal aspects of their work.

​

Press law procedures have several specificities:

​

• Short prescription periods: Most press offenses are subject to a statute of limitations of three months from the first publication.

​

• Specific criminal procedure: Procedural rules are adapted to ensure a balance between freedom of expression and individuals' rights.

​

• Jurisdictions with specialized competence: In Paris, the 17th criminal court is specialized in press cases.

​

It is important to note that press law is constantly evolving, particularly in response to the challenges posed by digital platforms and social media. Issues such as the liability of hosts, the right to be forgotten online, and the fight against misinformation are central to current debates and recent legislative changes.

​

Press law is a complex field that requires specialized expertise. Whether you are a media professional seeking to secure your publications, or an individual who believes their rights have been violated by an article or broadcast, it is essential to consult with a specialized lawyer. They will guide you through the intricacies of this specific legislation, defend your interests, and ensure compliance with the fundamental principles of freedom of expression and information.